Brita filter cartridges: the best alternative

Reading time: ~11 minutes

What are Brita filter cartridges?

Brita filter cartridges are the replaceable cartridges you place in a Brita water filter jug. In the Netherlands, "Brita filter cartridges" is searched for about 2,400 times a month, which shows how many households continuously buy new cartridges. Each cartridge contains activated carbon and an ion exchanger that primarily reduce chlorine and limescale to improve the taste of your tap water.

The most well-known cartridge is the Maxtra line, which fits almost all Brita jugs such as the Marella and the Aluna. Because you buy a cartridge repeatedly, this is essentially a subscription cost that can easily be overlooked. This is precisely why it pays to look for alternatives: cheaper, or a system where you have to replace much less often.

What types of Brita filter cartridges are there?

The difference between the cartridges mainly lies in their generation and what extra they reduce. These are the main variants you will find in stores:

• Classic: the oldest, blue cartridge for older Brita jugs. Primarily focuses on chlorine and limescale. A 3-pack costs around 13.76 euros.
• Maxtra+: the standard for years, with 4-stage filtration. A single cartridge costs about 39.95 euros for a larger pack.
• Maxtra Pro All-in-1: the current top variant that, according to the manufacturer, reduces not only chlorine and limescale but also copper, lead, and some modern substances like PFAS. Price approximately 22 to 28 euros for a 3-pack.
• Maxtra Pro Limescale Expert: aimed at maximum limescale reduction for kettles and coffee machines, around 23.76 euros.

Which cartridge is "the best" for you depends on your goal. If you mainly want better-tasting water and less limescale buildup, Maxtra Pro is sufficient. If you are looking for broader purification, you will encounter the limitations of a jug filter. A filter jug is different from a full-fledged purification system, and that difference ultimately determines which alternative makes sense.

What do Brita filter cartridges cost per year?

Here's the surprise. Brita advises replacing the Maxtra cartridge approximately every four weeks. That amounts to thirteen cartridges per year. If you calculate with an average of 8 to 10 euros per cartridge, you're looking at about 110 to 130 euros per year, just for replacement cartridges, on top of the cost of the jug itself.

In comparison: an under-sink replacement filter for the PureFilter Mineral+ costs 49.90 euros and lasts up to twelve months. That's about 0.14 euros per day, and you don't refill anything. So you pay less than half per year and save yourself 12 trips to get new cartridges. If you want to broaden that calculation, our explanation of the costs of a tap filter versus a fixed system can help.

Cheaper and compatible cartridges as an alternative

If you want to keep your current Brita jug but pay less, there are compatible cartridges from store brands. Brands like Sillar and Wessper make cartridges that fit Brita Maxtra jugs, often with the same activated carbon and ion exchanger and BPA-free.

• Compatible 12-packs: a 12-pack of a store brand costs around 30 to 33 euros, while an original Brita 12-pack can easily be double that.
• Promotions and value packs: "Brita filter cartridges offer" is deliberately searched for; if you buy in bulk or during a promotion, the price per cartridge drops.
• Where to buy: Brita and compatible cartridges can be found at Kruidvat, Action, Blokker, and online marketplaces.

It's important to be honest: compatible cartridges are cheaper, but do not carry the same certification as the original, and filter performance can vary by brand. Moreover, they do not solve the two real disadvantages of a jug filter, namely the constant refilling and limited purification. Thus, a jug filter primarily focuses on taste and not on a broad, certified approach to, for example, filtering PFAS from tap water or lead in tap water.

The real alternative: stopping refilling

The most chosen alternative for people who are tired of buying cartridges is an under-sink filter. You connect it once to the cold water line, and it filters directly at the tap, without a jug and without refilling. At PureFilter, we see that many customers started with a Brita jug and only switch when refilling becomes a hassle or they want more certainty about what exactly is removed from their water.

How the PureFilter Mineral+ is different

The PureFilter Mineral+ uses 5-stage filtration and is NSF certified (NSF 42, 53, 61, and 372). The system removes over 100 contaminants, including PFAS, microplastics, heavy metals, chlorine, and medicine residues, up to approximately 99 percent. Unlike a jug filter, it also adds calcium, magnesium, and potassium back through Swedish Mineral Rock™. The water not only becomes cleaner but also softer and richer in minerals. Installation takes 5 to 10 minutes, without a plumber or tools.

Dutch tap water is, by the way, of high quality and is strictly and daily monitored according to Milieu Centraal. So you filter not out of fear, but for extra assurance and taste. However, Milieu Centraal points out that water quality can actually deteriorate if bacteria grow on a poorly maintained filter, which is more likely to happen with a stagnant jug than with a flow-through system. The RIVM also states that tap water remains safe to drink and bottled water is 150 to 500 times more expensive, which makes an affordable fixed filter more attractive than continuously buying bottles.

Comparison table: cartridges side-by-side

Prices are indicative and vary by store and promotion. If you want to see Brita and our system point by point, we have a separate page where you can compare PureFilter and Brita. For a broader look at the brand, read our honest Brita water filter review.

Buying advice: which alternative suits you?

Choose based on your situation:

• You just want to save money: go for compatible cartridges or buy original cartridges in a value pack. You keep the jug but continue to refill.
• You're done with refilling and want broader purification: choose an under-sink filter. You only replace it once a year and remove many more substances.
• You're somewhere between a jug and a fixed system: read how to filter limescale from tap water, so you know which method yields the most for your water hardness.

If you are still unsure about a fixed filter, it's good to know that at PureFilter you can return it for free within 40 days and get a 5-year warranty. A good water filter for home doesn't have to be a gamble. If you want to compare available systems first, our guide on buying a water filter will help you further.

Frequently asked questions about Brita filter cartridges

Conclusion

Brita filter cartridges are a good entry point, but on an annual basis, they are a surprisingly expensive habit: quickly 110 to 130 euros and thirteen refills. If you primarily want to save money, compatible store-brand cartridges or value packs are the easiest alternative. If you want to stop refilling and have more certainty about what is removed from your water, then an under-sink filter like the PureFilter Mineral+ is the logical next step: one replacement per year, over 100 substances removed, and minerals added. This way, you pay less and drink fresher, softer, and more mineral-rich water.